No matter how hard we work to define beauty, art appreciation will always be to some extent subjective, simply because tastes vary. The music you love may grate on my nerves. Mine may put you to sleep. Is one better than the other? Not necessarily. Both may be technically excellent.
I watched one season of "So You Think You Can Dance" and was fascinated by the differing opinions of the experts. What one loved, another hated, and it mostly hinged on personal preference. All the dancers had proved their skill in audition before ever making it to the competition, so it wasn't a matter of ability. It was a combination of performance, personality, chemistry, charisma, and that indefinable quality that imbues any art with an element of mystery. The ache factor.
Many of you know that Relief Journal and Faith*in*Fiction recently co-sponsored the Daily Sacrament Short Story Contest. Our own Mark Bertrand and Dave Long of Bethany House judged the entries, and the top two stories will appear in the soon-to-release third issue of Relief. (You can order your copy now at the Relief site, if you haven't already.)
More than sixty people entered that contest. Don Hoesel won it, and Angie Poole was the runner up. Several other authors' pieces were featured on Dave's F*i*F blog as "stories of merit." So, what about the other 50+ stories? Do they, by default, stink? I somehow doubt it. I know of some terrific writers who entered that contest, and I'd love the opportunity to read their work. I also know I'm not alone in that interest.
After the winners were announced, several people suggested that other entrants post their stories on their blogs for the purpose of discussion. I think it's a great idea, so I'm going to be brave and step out on the dance floor right now. Let me emphasize that I'm not doing this so people will say that my Viennese Waltz is better or worse than So-and-So's Salsa or What's-His-Face's Foxtrot. I don't think it would be fruitful or edifying to draw those sorts of comparisons. But I'd love to hear what you think of my little dance based on its own merits--if it moves you or makes you think.
The contest theme of Daily Sacrament inspired some serious reflection, and I poured a bit of my soul into this story. I can honestly say writing it changed me, so if it accomplishes nothing else, that's a good thing, right?
Okay, enough stalling. Cue the music, maestro . . .
What's Left of Destiny
"Where's Jack?"
"Don't worry, Mrs. Calhoun. Jack is close by." He maneuvers her wheelchair around a pale amber puddle in the middle of the linoleum floor, shooting a sympathetic smile at Sam, the mop-wielding janitor.
Sam returns the smile and the sympathy, then nods at the wisp of a woman in the chair. "Evenin', Mrs. Calhoun."
Everyone around here knows better than to call her by her first name. That privilege belongs to Jack alone, and it's been almost three years since she's heard him use it.
"You're a good man, Sam," he says over his shoulder as he continues down the hall. And he means it.
Folks say Sam was a local baseball legend in his youth. Could have made it in the majors, if only he hadn't suffered that shoulder injury. If only. Now there's a dead-end road he's traveled more times than he can count. No. There is no if only. For whatever reason, Sam's path landed him mopping up unidentified bodily fluids in a place where most peoples' minds exited stage left long ago. And he does it with cheerful dignity. You gotta respect someone like that.
As for his own path, for the moment it leads to the door at the end of this hallway. These days he tries to take things one at a time.
He taps lightly on the door. When no one responds he opens it and pulls the wheelchair inside. An oversized tub dominates the room. He twists the stainless steel knobs, adjusts the temperature, then squats in front of the shrunken form seated in the chair. "Ready for your bath, Mrs. Calhoun?"
She raises her head from its usual lolled position. He knows that look. Fear mixed with defiance. She darts her eyes as though looking for a way to escape. "Who are you? Where’s Jack?"
"Don't worry. Jack is close by. He knows you're with me." He says a silent prayer that her terror won't escalate into hysterics again. Last Wednesday she tried to fight him and he barely managed to keep her from falling. After the last hip surgery, doctors warned the staff that her bones have become so brittle, her forearm could snap as easily as a dried branch.
"Who are you?" She growls the words through clenched teeth, her eyes narrow and suspicious.
He's never quite sure how to answer that question, because, no matter what he says, it upsets her. "It's okay. I'm going to help you with your bath."
She raises a bony finger. "Jack's not gonna like this. You’ll be sorry when he gets back."
"Jack knows, Mrs. Calhoun. He asked me to help you."
Her expression softens a little then goes blank. Her head drifts back to its rut--tilted to the right, chin low. He takes advantage of the lull and gently unsnaps the front of her cotton house coat. A thin stream of drool trickles onto his hand.
"Where's Jack?" Her voice is little more than a whisper now.
"Don't worry. Jack is close by." He hates to lie, but it's the only way to keep her calm. He rolls a reclining bath gurney beside her chair and locks the wheels on both. "Okay, now. I'm going to help you move to this gurney for your bath. Let's place your arms around my neck. There you go."
He positions her feet on the floor, then leans forward and slides his hands behind her back, gathering the fabric of her house coat into his fists before gently lifting her. She weighs no more than eighty-five pounds, but he can't be sure she won't panic mid-transfer, so he acts with the adept confidence of experience. In one motion he shifts her to the gurney and slips her house coat over her head.
She giggles, her
breath warm on his neck. "I'm not paralyzed, ya know. I can take off my own
nightie."
"Shh. You don't want
to wake the kids." He tosses her gown on the rug. "I just thought I'd be
helpful." He plants a kiss behind her ear. Her hair smells like a garden.
"You always were the
altruistic one." She laughs with abandon now, and he buries his smile in her
thick brown hair. The first time he heard her musical laughter--the irrepressible
soundtrack of her life--he knew he wanted to hear it every day for the rest of
his life.
This room is kept at eighty degrees, but she shivers against the vinyl padding. He covers her with a thick towel, then positions the gurney over the tub and presses a lever that lowers it into the water. When it reaches the water's surface he removes the towel. She visibly relaxes as her body submerges in the warm water.
This time she asks the question with closed eyes and a half smile. "Where's Jack?"
Soaking in a hot bath is one of her few remaining pleasures, so he doesn't rush the process. He scoots a chair beside the tub and studies her face, wondering what's going through her mind. "I suppose Jack went to get coffee. You know how much he loves coffee."
A thin smile presses against furrows of unyielding skin. "Hm. He sure does love his coffee."
He dips a washcloth in the water and rubs it with a bar of soap. "You just lay back and relax, Mrs. Calhoun. I'm going to wash your legs and feet first." He eases a withered leg above the surface, massaging the gnarled foot, dabbing at the cracked, yellow toenails. He works his way up her leg, gently scrubbing splotchy skin that sags off her bones like soggy crepe paper.
"You’ll get sunburn if
you lay there much longer."
She hands him the
lotion without looking up from her book. "Fine then."
He squeezes a white glob
into his palm, rubs his hands together, then smooths it on her leg. How could
something as ordinary as a leg be so beautiful? The contour of her muscles
beneath his touch. The delicate ankle and curve of her heel. And those tiny
brown freckles on her skin.
He's completely undone
by those freckles.
He washes one leg, then the other. Then her arms. She submits without resistance. Most evenings she doesn't protest until he lifts her torso out of the warm water, so he puts that off as long as possible. He sets the washcloth aside and reaches for the shampoo.
Her white hair is smashed and matted in back from her pillow. The top looks like she hired Albert Einstein as a stylist. Using a hand-held shower head, he directs a soothing stream over her scalp. The wild hair collapses into thin clumps against pink skin. He lathers her hair with shampoo, patiently unknotting the mats with his fingers, careful not to pull too hard. If he hurts her, she'll let him know.
"Ouch! Geez, do you
have to yank so hard?" She rubs the back of her head.
"Sorry! Next time
you're wearing a hat."
They'd rented a
convertible to drive the perimeter of the island. Half the fun for him had been
watching her waist-length hair whip around her face and listening to her laugh.
Now they're both
paying for the pleasure. She sits Indian-style on the hotel deck in front of a
small stool where he's been perched for a good twenty minutes, detangling her
mane. So far he's conquered only about a third of it--easing the brush through by
inches, stopping when it snags to work out the snarl.
He pauses to stretch
his back and survey his handiwork. The setting sun seduces her copper highlights,
and they yield to its touch with a flash of fiery desire. Everything about this
woman intoxicates him.
She leans her head back and pouts at him
upside down. "I'm sorry I complained. Do I really have to wear a hat next
time?"
He gathers the mass of
hair pooling around her hips and raises it to his lips like a chalice of fine
wine. She owns him. "What do you think?"
She dozed off while he washed her hair. The snoring was a dead give away. But as much as he hates to wake her, the time has come. He raises the gurney until her chest rises above the water.
She startles and opens her eyes, her pupils contracting to pinpoints as she tries to focus. "Where's Jack?" The fear has returned.
"Don't worry, Mrs. Calhoun. Jack is close by."
"Who are you? Why are you touching me?" She clutches his wrist.
He dips the washcloth in the water with his free hand. "I'm giving you a bath. You were so comfortable, you fell asleep."
Her grip is amazingly strong for such a frail person. "Jack's not gonna like this. You'll be sorry when he gets back."
"Jack knows. You'll feel better when you're nice and clean."
"I don't like you. I want Jack."
It's much harder when she gets obstinate. He takes a deep breath. "I understand you want Jack. I wish . . . let's just finish your bath and we'll go look for him, okay? Now, will you let go of my wrist?"
He waits for her to release her claw-like grip, then re-lathers the washcloth and begins to soap her sunken chest. She has no breasts. They were removed by mastectomy twelve years ago. During this part of the process he avoids looking into her eyes and focuses on the task at hand.
When he rinses off the soap, her thin scars glisten white like swords barring the way to the woman she once was.
She stood before him
today with the surrender of a bride. So trusting. So perfect.
"In the name of God, I take thee to be my
wife, to have and to hold from this day forward, for better for worse, for
richer for poorer, in sickness and in health, to love and to cherish, until we
are parted by death. This is my solemn vow."
He slipped a gold band on her slender finger. "With this ring I thee wed,
with my body I thee worship, and with all my worldly goods I thee endow; in the
name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost; Amen."
He'd saved himself for
marriage. So had she. Sometimes he'd wondered if they'd make it to the
honeymoon, but somehow, with God's help, they did. And now the time has come.
She's in the bathroom "getting ready." He feels . . . nervous, yes. But mostly excited. And happy.
Unbelievably happy.
She enters the room
wearing a pale blue gauzy gown. He's never seen her look more beautiful. Or
more shy.
"Turn off the light."
He obeys.
She steps close to him
and unties the satin string at her neckline. The gown drops to the floor.
Her skin is striped by
moonlight slanting through the blinds. His heart pounds against his chest as he
slips his arms around her waist and pulls her close.
With my body I thee
worship.
She kisses him. Then
she laughs.
As usual the bath took almost an hour. He wheels her through the dim hallway back to her room, helps her into a fresh nightgown, and transfers her to the bed.
"Where's Jack?" Her voice is sleepy.
"Jack is close by."
This is my solemn vow.
He fluffs her pillow and makes sure her nightgown isn't bunched beneath her. Then he adjusts her covers and turns off the light.
He sits in the chair across the room. Moonlight slants through the blinds.
From this day forward.
Until we are parted by death.
She's asleep. Her snoring has always been a dead give away. Still he waits. She often talks in the early stages of sleep, giving him brief glimpses into happy dreams. Dreams where she finally finds Jack again.
But tonight she's silent. He rises and tiptoes to the door. "Good-night, Destiny," he whispers. "Sweet dreams."
He steps into the hallway and eases the door to a crack.
"Jack!"
In one giant step he's back in the room, holding his breath, silencing the pain for the sake of the joy. He strains to hear, but these sounds are not words. Something's wrong. He reaches for the light switch, then stops.
For one eternal moment the stone is rolled away, beautifying his scars, freeing his heart from its tomb.
She's laughing.
Well, if all 60 entries were as good as this then I can imagine Mark and Dave had a really, really hard time determining the winner. It also augers well for the depth of ability out there so that Relief will never have to worry about running out of good material.
I loved this story. Beautifully done. Its emotional power built.
I got a little bit confused off the top with who was who, but that's just a tiny quibble.
Thanks for publishing it here!
Deb
Posted by: Deborah Gyapong | May 17, 2007 at 07:23 AM
This is absolutely stunning, Jeanne. Love it. Thanks for posting it.
Posted by: relevantgirl | May 17, 2007 at 08:15 AM
Beautiful.
Posted by: Linda Gilmore | May 17, 2007 at 09:33 AM
I'm so glad you decided to share, Jeanne. What a passionate story! You described commitment, love, honor and marriage in a light is at once beautiful and sad, yet happy.
There was most certainly a sense of the mundane becoming holy and the story could have happened any given day for Jack, but this one day was special.
I cried when I read this and I understood it, even though I maybe didn't want to because it took me to a place that I don't want to imagine myself or Phil in, but he would do it for me. I suppose that's why I cried and am crying now, the characters were so real they impacted me on several levels.
This story is an example of what I thought I'd be reading. I've read Angie's and hers worked for me as well, it was layered, deep, and meaningful. Her characters were also real, all of these are people I could have in my life.
Thank you again for sharing. I loved this story and the hidden meaning in the title.
Posted by: Michelle Pendergrass | May 17, 2007 at 10:33 AM
Jeanne,
You paint beautifully.
M
Posted by: Madison Richards | May 17, 2007 at 01:40 PM
Test
Posted by: test | May 17, 2007 at 01:58 PM
I cried, too. Beautiful story.
Posted by: Suzan | May 17, 2007 at 02:03 PM
Jeanne you put your foot in that story. I like it a lot.
Thanks for posting your story so that we can see how others worked through this contest.
I posted my story on my blog and I don't like my story. I would love some help on making it better.
Posted by: Dee Stewart | May 17, 2007 at 02:16 PM
Oh my, Jeanne. What else can I say? Breath-taking (a cliche, I know, but that's all that comes to me).
Posted by: Heather Goodman | May 17, 2007 at 02:40 PM
Thanks for sharing, Jeanne. I'm not as smart as everyone else here, so it took me a read through to grasp what was really happening - but that made me enjoy it even more.
Posted by: Tina | May 17, 2007 at 04:01 PM
Really, nicely done. The details were perfect. Took me right back to the nursing home days and to the Alzheimer patients I worked with.
The sacrifice he makes for her though she doesn't even recognize him works and the fact that we so often fight Christ as he tries to wash us...this worked on several levels.
sally
Posted by: sally apokedak | May 17, 2007 at 06:44 PM
Ah, Jeanne, I loved this. I agree with Michelle that this was the kind of story I was expecting to read too. And, having read Angie's, I see many similarities. Beautiful and graceful as your work always is. Thank you so much for posting it.
Posted by: Jennifer Tiszai | May 17, 2007 at 08:48 PM
Really enjoyed this, Jeanne. Very well done.
Posted by: Don Hoesel | May 17, 2007 at 11:08 PM
Thanks, everyone, for taking the time to read and comment. You're all so generous and kind.
This story makes me cry, too. Partly because I'm a dork. (I also laugh at my own jokes, even if no one else thinks they're funny.) But mostly because I can see all ends of this spectrum from where I sit. I'm turning fifty this year, my parents are getting old, and my daughter's getting married soon. I wrote with a crowded heart.
One thing I love most about story is how it speaks different things to different people. Sally, thanks for sharing your thoughts about Christ's sacrifice in spite of our blindness, and also our attempts to resist His cleansing. You made me think in new ways.
Thanks, Don. And congratulations! I'm eagerly anticipating yours.
Posted by: Jeanne Damoff | May 18, 2007 at 12:22 AM
Are you sponsored by Kleenex????
Good heavens, woman, this is good :-)
Posted by: Angie | May 18, 2007 at 09:22 PM
Thanks, Angie. Can't wait to learn me a few lizard secrets. ;)
Posted by: Jeanne Damoff | May 19, 2007 at 10:44 AM
Absolutely lovely. I didn't cry -- I smiled; it was really beautiful! I'm itching for more of the Daily Sacrament stories.
Posted by: Eliza | May 20, 2007 at 09:23 AM
Jeanne, you already know this. But I love the way you write. And this is no exception. Beautifully done. Thanks for sharing.
Posted by: michael snyder | May 21, 2007 at 02:14 PM